丑陋的闾丘露薇

丑陋的闾丘露薇

事件来自于闾丘露薇转发和评论的一条视频:小孩当街大小便,大陆夫妻与港人激烈冲突。在这个事件中,身为新闻工作者的闾丘露薇完全缺乏职业素养,后续访谈和评论中,简单地以“不了解舆情”做借口更让人无法接受。

根据视频的内容,大陆夫妻是在厕所人多排队排不上、小孩憋不住的情况下,才在公共场合不得已而为之。而且小孩妈妈很显然用尿不湿等物品托着,并装进了自己带的纸袋中。闾丘露薇后来的说辞“找个角落避避”貌似很有道理,但是回避了一个简单的事实:那是在旺角!好吗!请您在节假日的旺角那几条街找个没人的角落出来!

其他评论更是罔顾事实:例如女子打人耳光、抢夺相机等。孩子妈妈阻止港人抢夺婴儿车,怎么就被指责为打人了?从视频中也很明显可以看到,是港人故意拖拽婴儿车,肆无忌惮地给人拍照(甚至拍私处!!)!

随手转发视频很容易,但是作为职业新闻工作者,难道没有看完视频才做判断?难道不应该了解一些基本情况再做评论?评论的时候难道不应该站在客观的立场?

事后的一些访谈和博文,更显得强词夺理、回避事实,完全无视客观、公正。自以为代表正义,却忽视了尊重事实这个基本的道理。大陆的确有很多让人看不起的地方,但这不等于就可以随便践踏事实。

整件事、整个人只能用一个词形容:丑陋!闾丘露薇应该停止争辩,并立刻道歉。犯错不可耻,可耻的是强词夺理!

2014-04-29 updated:

在网上看到据传是陈道明先生的评论,感觉很钦佩。对比闾丘露薇,真是美丑立现:

文明的意义除了不当街便溺,还有善意与宽容,前者是表象,后者才是根本。真正的文明,是碰到这样的情况,走过去善意咨询那位母亲是否需要帮忙,或者指引她找到厕所,而不是冷漠地拍照当成渲染大陆人素质低下的又一个证据。大陆人的素质的确有待提高,但香港人的文明同样需要提升。

2016-06-19 updated:

一位外国人评论:

It has been my understanding that Hong Kong people have always had an animosity towards mainland Chinese. There have been numerous times when Chinese people were looked down upon. I remember reading an article of a little girl who could not hold her bladder so, her mom got out a diaper and let her urinate on it. During this incident, there were some Hong Kong people who were taking videos of this incident causing a lot of trouble saying how uncivilized mainland Chinese people were. I’m American and all I know is this. If some pedophile tried to take a video of my 5 year old daughter urinating, I’d give them a serious beat down.

Comments are closed.